Song story

Why Can't This Be Love by Van Halen

Why Can't This Be Love is a 1986 song by Van Halen, from the album 5150. Here are 9 checked facts about it, the same ones your Stationz DJ can tell before the song plays. Every fact comes from the sources listed at the end of the page.

Part of the story of Van Halen · Researched by Stationz.fm

The facts behind Why Can't This Be Love

  1. Milestone

    Why Can't This Be Love marked a major turning point for Van Halen. It was the group's first single featuring new singer Sammy Hagar after he replaced founding frontman David Lee Roth.

  2. Trivia

    When the track came out, it dropped on both seven-inch and twelve-inch formats. If you picked up the twelve-inch version, you got a special extended cut with extra lyrics.

  3. On the charts

    The track was a major hit across the airwaves. In the US, it reached number three on the Billboard Hot 100 and soared all the way to number one on Cashbox.

  4. In the studio

    Sammy Hagar explained that while previous tracks like Jump sounded like synthesizers, this keyboard riff sounded like a guitar. Even though some hardcore guitar fans rebelled, it brought the band a brand-new audience.

  5. Trivia

    Not everyone embraced the track right away. Writing for Vulture, critic Chuck Klosterman dubbed it the worst Van Halen song and called releasing it as Hagar's debut the worst decision the band ever made.

  6. The story

    During the 5150 and OU812 tours, Eddie Van Halen performed the keyboard parts using equipment connected to an offstage synth. That left Sammy Hagar to play the guitar parts and take the solo.

  7. The story

    The live arrangement shifted starting with the For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge tour. Eddie Van Halen took over guitar duties again, and the song's keyboard parts were moved entirely backstage.

  8. The story

    Starting on the 1995 Balance tour, bassist Michael Anthony and Eddie Van Halen took over lead vocals for the second verse. They kept up that tradition during the band's 1998 and 2004 tours.

  9. The lyrics

    The song gets teased for the line 'Only time will tell if we stand the test of time.' Back in 2008, The Daily Telegraph labeled it the eighth worst lyric of all time.

Sources

More about Van Halen

Van HalenThe story of Van HalenVan Halen was an American hard rock band formed in Pasadena, California, by the Dutch born brothers Eddie and Alex Van Halen, with singer David Lee Roth and bassist Mich…

Hear Why Can't This Be Love on the radio

Hear the story before the song

Stationz is an AI radio DJ for YouTube. Play Why Can't This Be Love in any playlist and your DJ introduces it with facts like these, then lets the music play.